Our Hay Varieties

We’re super excited: we now have multiple varieties of hay to choose from. See below for our current hay products and a brief description of each.

You can also browse the full collection on our Hay Collection page.

1st Cutting Timothy

The first harvest of the summer. This cut contains the most seed-heads and stems with little leaf. It’s higher in fiber, making it great for digestion and dental wear.

2nd Cutting Timothy

Our most popular choice among customers. It has a balanced mix of stem, seed-head, and leaf, with a mid to high amount of fiber. A reliable everyday staple for most pets.

3rd Cutting / Super Soft Timothy

The softest of our Timothy hays. It has very little stem or seed-head and is mostly leaf. Perfect for picky pets or those with dental sensitivities.

Ultra-Soft Premium Timothy

Our rarest and softest Timothy hay, hand-selected for its leafiness and minimal stem. Pets who are picky, recovering from illness, or dealing with dental issues often love this hay. It’s tender, nutrient-rich, and an excellent option when only the highest quality will do.

Orchard

A very soft, all-leaf hay that’s a favorite among picky pets and those with dental challenges. It’s also an excellent choice for pet parents who are allergic to Timothy hay.

Oat

A crunchy, flavorful hay with seed heads that pets love to forage through. High in fiber and perfect for mixing in with other hays to add variety. It’s also a great Timothy alternative for allergy-sensitive households.

Alfalfa

Packed with nutrients and higher in protein and calcium. Alfalfa is the go-to for young, growing pets and seniors who need a nutritional boost. It’s also another option for those with Timothy allergies.

Gourmet

A fragrant blend of hay infused with herbs and flowers to create an irresistible treat while adding variety to your pet’s diet.

Can’t Decide? Try the Sampler Box!

Our Sampler Hay Box makes it easy by including 2 lbs. each of four customer favorites:

• 2nd Cutting “Perfect Blend” Timothy

• 3rd Cutting “Super Soft” Timothy

• Orchard Hay

• Oat Hay

Mmmmmm. Remember, our little animals naturally eat a wide variety of grasses in the wild, so they really appreciate variety. The sampler is a great way to discover your pet’s preferences before committing to a larger box.

If you’re still not sure which hay will be best for your pet, download our free hay e-book to help guide your decision.