Small Pet Select logo
Small Pet Select logo

All articles

Shipping, Policies and Guarantees

Return Policy

Returns. If you or your pet aren’t satisfied with your purchase, you may request a return within 14 days of receipt for most products. We do not accept returns for:. Open food items, treats, or bedding. Opened hay, for health and safety reasons. Cust

Picky Pet Promise - Satisfaction Guarantee

We stand behind the quality of our products. It's all part of our Picky Pet Promise, also known as our Satisfaction Guarantee. If you or your pet aren't satisfied with your order, contact us within 14 days of receipt and we'll review the situation wi

Shipping Policy – Fast & Furriest Shipping!

Shipping Policy – Fast & Furriest Shipping!At Small Pet Select, we’re committed to getting fresh products to you and your pets as quickly as possible. Our Shipping CarriersStarting September 30, 2026, orders over 15 oz ship with FedEx Home Delivery.

Shipping Fulfillment and Updates: Weather, Holidays, and Carrier Impacts

How weekend warehouse hours, weather, holidays, and carrier schedules can affect your order, plus tips for keeping an emergency stash of hay and food on hand.

Expedited Shipping Options and Special Handling Requests

For expedited shipping or special handling requests, please call our Customer Success team at 855-981-8080 so we can take your order over the phone. This lets us coordinate with our warehouse in real time. If you need overnight shipping or would like

Shipping Restrictions & PO Box Information

We ship only to physical street addresses, not P.O. Boxes. Learn which carrier ships your order and how to avoid address errors at checkout.

Policy Exceptions

We want to be upfront about the few situations where our regular policies don’t apply. This page brings together all our exclusions for the Picky Pet Promise, returns, and discount codes so you have everything in one place. Our Picky Pet Promise mean

Refunds, Replacements, and Store Credit

Refunds, Replacements, and Store Credit. We’re pet parents too, and we want you (and your crew) to be happy with your order. If something arrives damaged, incorrect, or not as expected, please contact us within 14 days of receipt so we can help. Ther

Privacy & Trackers Concern

Why does my browser say your site has so many trackers?. Some browsers and privacy tools count every script our site uses and call them “trackers.” These tools help your cart work, show you past items, and keep the site running smoothly, so the numbe

Privacy & Email Use

We value your privacy and do not sell or share your personal information with outside parties. We may use your email address to send follow-up or retargeting emails about our products, promotions, or updates you might be interested in. You can opt ou

How is my hay packaged and shipped?

Learn about our hay box styles, which sizes come in which box type, and why we ship hay directly in its box without an outer shipping box.